Santa Clara Family Health Plan Small Group Insurance Program Expected Cost Analysis 2006-08-07
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Expected Cost Analysis
August 7,2006
Executive Summary
The objective of this analysis was to determine the expected monthly cost of providing medical
coverage in currently uninsured individuals who work for small employers - defined as
employers with less than 50 employees who do not currently provide health insurance. The
insurance would only be available to the employee; dependent coverage would not be offered.
Buck also modeled the impact of the baseline claim costs running 5% lower and 5% higher than
projected. These variations provide additional information on the likely volatility of the actual
experience under the program.
While there are approximately 48,000 individuals that could be covered under the plan, based on
the survey conducted by the Santa Clara Family Health Plan, not all of the members would
participate. We used to results of the survey and the contribution rates that were developed in
our analysis to determine the expected participation rates. Based on the survey, we expect
approximately 65% of the eligible employees to enroll.
The expected cost of the program on a per enrolled participant basis increases as the participation
percentage decreases. As enrollment decreases, the underlying risk characteristics of the enrolled
population increases. This means that typically, the healthier portion of a population is the first
to elect not to participate, which increases the expected cost for the remaining population.
Because of this risk, we recommend that the initial premium rates be set assuming that only 60%
of the eligible employees enroll. This assumption will produce premium rates that provide
additional margin to cover adverse experience.
Table 1 shows the recommended premium rates and participant contributions by age band
assuming that the participant contributes 1/3 of the cost(and the remaining 2/3 is split between
the health plans and the employer).
Table 1
Small Group Insurance Program
Rates Effective January 1, 2007
Participant
Recommended Contribution
Premium
33.33%
40-64
$190.23
$204.60
$393.89
$63.41
$68.20
$131.30
Composite
$262.60
$87.53
Under 25
25-39
The table shows that the monthly contribution for the eligible employees ranges from $63.41 to
$131.30 assuming the 1/3 contribution for both employees and employers. If the health plans
elect to go with composite rates instead of age banded rates, the contributions are $87.53 for both
the employee and the employer.
The remainder of this report provides more detail on the methods and assumptions used to
develop the final cost estimates.
2
Development of Cost Estimates
This section describes the methodology used to develop the recommended premium rates, the
expected total cost, participant contributions, and net health plan costs for the new benefit plans
for eligible employees. This program is intended to provide coverage to eligible small group
employers and their employees who do not have coverage and have income of less than 300% of
the federal poverty level.
The first step was the development of the expected cost and utilization experience of the
expansion population. We used Medi-Cal experience for the four county area and our
proprietary cost and utilization databases to develop the expected cost patterns for this
population. Our proprietary model is built from Medi-Cal data for the State of California,
supplemented by Medicaid experience in other western U.S. states, OSHPD hospital data for the
State of California, and other employer based data sources for the Western U.S.
This model allows us to develop the expected per member per month(PMPM)claim costs for
the eligible population. Since this is primarily an uninsured or under-insured population, we
developed adjustment to reflect the estimated impact of pent-up demand. Exhibit VII provides
the detailed expected cost and utilization experience used in the analysis. The exhibit shows the
expected utilization rates per 1,000 covered members and the expected cost per service for each
detailed benefit category. W based the projections on the assumption that the fee schedule used
to pay providers would be consistent with Medicare reimbursement rates.
It then shows the impact of any per service copayment amount and the net expected cost on a
PMPM basis. The resulting claim costs were then loaded by 10% to account for the expected
administrative cost of the program. Table 2 below summarizes the general benefit provisions
that were used to develop the expected plan costs. This is based on the IHSS program offered in
San Mateo County and the VSP vision plan provided by Santa Clara Family Health Plan.
Table 2
Small Group Insurance Program
Category
Benefit
Hospitalization
Outpatient
Emergency
Maternity
Prescription
Drugs
Covered.
Covered. $5 co-payment
Covered. $25 co-payment - waived if admitted.
Covered.
Covered. Limited formulary. $5 co-payment. $25 co-payment for
name brands with generic equivalents. 30 day supply.
3
The second step was to develop the expected eligible and participating population for the
program. The Santa Clara Family Health Plan provided this data. Based on this data, there are
approximately 14,000 eligible employees who could be covered under this plan. In addition, the
survey provided information on the likelihood the eligible employers would offer coverage and
the likelihood that employees would enroll in coverage based on the required member premium
contribution. We were requested to develop participant contribution rates of 1/3 of the premium
rates for the eligible employees. An additional 1/3 would be paid by the employer and the health
plans would subsidize the remaining 1/3. In addition, we assumed that if the employee lost their
employment they could continue the coverage if they paid both the employer and employee
portion, or 2/3 of the cost.
Based on the data provided, we estimate that approximately 71% of the 14,000 employees would
participate. In addition, we assumed that 10% of the participating employees would lose
coverage and of those, 50% would elect to continue coverage. This means that in total about
75% of the eligible population would participate in the program. The total expected enrollment
under the composite rating method and under the age based rating method is shown in Exhibit IV
for the two groups of eligible employees.
The third step in the analysis was to develop the expected premium costs based on participation
level. Exhibit IV shows the expected premium costs for the two contribution scenarios. It then
shows the expected cost as the participation level falls. As enrollment decreases, the underlying
risk characteristics of the enrolled population increases. This means that typically, the healthier
portion of a population is the first to elect not to participate, which increases the expected cost on
a PMPM basis for the remaining population.
Since the expected participation rate for the employees is approximately 71% of the eligible
employees, we recommend that the health plan set the rates at the 60% participation rate level to
provide some additional conservatism in the initial rates for the plan.
Exhibit VI shows the monthly cost share for the eligible employees for the various participation
levels and the recommended 60% participation rates. It shows the contribution rates by age
range and on a composite basis for the two contribution rate scenarios. The contribution rates for
the higher participation scenarios will never apply because it is unlikely that a high percentage of
the eligible employees will enroll. To help control the risk and provide a higher likelihood that
the premium rates will cover the cost of the plan, we recommend that the 60% participation level
be used to develop the premiums and contributions for the plan.
The final step was to develop the expected total premium income, total plan cost, and net health
plan costs as well as the costs if the baseline claim costs run 5% lower and 5% higher than
projected for the two premium contribution scenarios. These variations provide the health plans
additional information on the likely volatility of the actual experience under the program.
Exhibit I-A through I-C provide the detailed results for the composite and age based rate options
separately for the first five years of the program. It combines the results for the employees who
are paying 1/3 of the cost and those who are paying 2/3 of the cost. Exhibit I-A provides the
expected results and Exhibits 1-B and I-C provides the results for the two sensitivity analysis
scenarios.
4
The exhibits first show the estimated number of eligible employees who will elect coverage. It
then shows the total premium rate collection, the total expected plan cost, the participant
contributions, the employer contribution, and the net health plan cost for each year. The
premium rates are based on the 60% participation level, while the costs are based on the
expected cost for each health plan individually. Since we expect almost 71% of the eligible
employees to enroll under this scenario, the underlying risk is improved and the cost is expected
to be less than the premium cost.
The exhibits show that using the 60% participation rate as the basis for developing the premium
rates protects the program if costs are equal to expected or are less than expected. If costs are
5% higher than expected then the program runs a deficit. The recommended premium rates will
provide protection if actual costs are up to 2.2% higher than expected.
Exhibits II-A through II-C provide the detailed results for the first five years of the program for
the employees who are contributing 33.3% of the premium cost(and the employer and health
plan evenly split the other 2/3 of the premium cost). Exhibit II-A provides the expected results
and Exhibits II-B and II-C provides the results for the two sensitivity analysis scenarios.
The exhibits first show the estimated number of eligible employees who will elect coverage for
each participating health plan. It then shows the total premium rate collection, the total expected
plan cost, the participant contributions, the employer contribution, and the net health plan cost
for each year. The premium rates are based on the 60% participation level, while the costs are
based on the expected cost for each contribution scenario. Since we expect almost 71% of the
eligible employees to enroll under this scenario, the underlying risk is slightly improved, so the
cost is expected to be less than the premium cost.
The exhibits show that using the 60% participation rate as the basis for developing the premium
rates protects the program if costs are equal to expected or are less than expected. If costs are
5% higher than expected then the program runs a deficit. The recommended premium rates will
provide protection if actual costs are up to 2.5% higher than expected.
Exhibits III-A through III-C provide the detailed results for the first five years of the program for
the employees who are contributing 66.7% of the premium cost. Exhibit III-A provides the
expected results and Exhibits III-B and III-C provides the results for the two sensitivity analysis
scenarios.
The exhibits first show the estimated number of eligible employees who will elect coverage for
each participating health plan. It then shows the total premium rate collection, the total expected
plan cost, the participant contributions, the employer contribution, and the net health plan cost
for each year. The premium rates are based on the 60% participation level, while the costs are
based on the expected cost for each contribution scenario. These individuals are likely to be
higher risk, so the exhibit shows that the premiums are not likely to cover the expected costs
under any of the three sensitivity scenarios.
5
The exhibits show that these individuals will create a loss of approximately 5.5% to 6.5% of the
premium rates depending on whether the age based or composite rates are used. If their
experience is 5% better than expected these losses fall to 0.2% to 1.2%. If costs are 5% higher
than expected then the deficit increases to 10.8% to 11.8%. The expected high utilization of this
population is one of the key reasons to set the premium rates conservatively yet not so
conservative as to discourage enrollment in the program.
For Exhibit I, Exhibit II, and Exhibit III the premium rates, plan costs, and participant
contributions are assumed to increase 8% per year.
6
Exhibit I-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
Combined33.3% and 66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Composite
Number of Participants
Workers
Total
35,805
12,948
14,390
8,656
35,994
Year 1
$112,828,716
$29,557,176
$105,801,647
$121,855,872
$131,604,858
$142,135,825
$153,504,629
$31,921,999
$34,476,381
$37,232,751
$40,211,309
$35,330,328
$38,155,373
$40,914,143
Year 2
$44,186,111
$41,208,355
$44,504,816
$48,065,478
$47,720,875
$51,539,209
$55,661,888
$114,263,483
$123,405,611
$133,276,776
$143,938,675
$110,476,666
$119,320,812
$29,002,551
$31,323,149
$33,828,204
$34,677,664
$37,452,026
$39,967,472
$43,164,632
$40,447,153
$46,617,625
$103,647,687
$111,939,807
$120,892,982
$36,534,900
$39,457,221
$43,683,669
$47,179,038
$50,347,276
$130,565,845
$54,375,426
$141,011,685
$10,440,583
$12,441,317
$11,275,369
$14,204,528
$13,435,527
$14,511,829
$15,672,046
$16,925,299
$13,975,572
$15,093,192
$16,300,222
$17,604,112
$19,012,312
$36,857,472
$39,804,088
$42,989,713
$46,428,560
$50,142,139
$9,264,201
$10,004,928
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$12,604,047
$11,112,235
$12,000,236
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$13,301,215
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Total Premium Rates
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
$128,864,092
$139,170,569
Year 5
$150,304,887
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$39,296,068
Year 2
$42,443,166
Year 3
$45,837,183
Year 4
$49,505,055
Year 5
$53,464,741
$12,177,662
$13,152,402
Employer Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$35,920,211
$38,796,947
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$48,871,678
Exhibit I-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
Combined 33.3% and 66.67%) Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$35,260,387
$38,080,699
$41,127,519
$44,413,352
$47,968,468
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
$2,352,050
Year 2
$2,535,060
Year 3
$2,740,766
Year 4
$2,965,256
Year 5
$3,199,742
$9,297,767
$10,042,852
$10,844,986
$11,712,030
$12,648,646
$554,625
$652,664
$598,850
$648,177
$703,347
$761,202
$697,851
$754,088
$821,147
$886,440
$11,124,112
$12,690,685
$12,016,263
$13,706,533
$12,973,765
$14,013,791
$15,136,537
$14,803,708
$15,988,495
$17,268,194
$33,112,564
$35,765,648
$38,622,459
$41,714,316
$45,053,377
$946,671
$1,021,479
$2,153,960
$1,103,250
$2,512,629
$1,191,933
$2,710,931
$2,926,990
$1,286,462
$2,323,676
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
Exhibit I-B
Combined 33.3% and 66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Number of Participants
Workers
35,805
12,948
14,390
8,656
35,994
$112,828,716
$121,855,872
$131,604,858
$142,135,825
$153,504,629
$29,557,176
$31,921,999
$34,476,381
$37,232,751
$40,211,309
$35,330,328
$38,155,373
$41,208,355
$44,504,816
$48,065,478
$40,914,143
$44,186,111
$47,720,875
$51,539,209
$55,661,888
$105,801,647
$114,263,483
$123,405,611
$133,276,776
$143,938,675
$104,952,833
$113,354,771
$122,420,887
$132,212,041
$142,789,642
$27,552,423
$29,756,992
$32,943,781
$35,579,425
$38,424,795
$41,499,485
$44,820,087
$37,969,098
$41,006,401
$44,286,744
$47,829,912
$51,656,655
$98,465,302
$12,441,317
$13,975,572
$15,093,192
$16,300,222
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$39,296,068
Year 2
$42,443,166
Year 3
$45,837,183
Year 4
$49,505,055
Year 5
$53,464,741
$32,136,794
$34,708,155
$37,484,360
$10,440,583
$11,275,369
$12,177,662
$13,152,402
$14,204,528
$13,435,527
$14,511,829
$15,672,046
$16,925,299
$17,604,112
$19,012,312
$9,264,201
$10,004,928
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$12,604,047
$11,112,235
$12,000,236
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$13,301,215
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
$106,342,818
$114,848,333
$124,037,552
$133,961,102
$36,857,472
$39,804,088
$42,989,713
$46,428,560
$50,142,139
Employer Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$35,920,211
$38,796,947
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$48,871,678
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
Exhibit I-B
Combined 33.3% and 66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$29,736,554
$32,114,658
$34,684,314
$37,454,824
$40,453,223
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
$7,875,883
Year 2
$8,501,101
Year 3
$9,183,971
Year 4
$9,923,784
Year 5
$10,714,987
$7,847,639
$8,476,695
$9,153,576
$9,885,285
$10,675,785
$9,390,229
$10,143,662
$10,951,407
$11,829,607
$12,777,586
$10,692,311
$11,548,302
$12,472,827
$13,471,131
$14,549,423
$32,577,810
$35,186,023
$38,002,794
$2,004,753
$2,386,547
$2,575,948
$2,783,560
$3,005,331
$3,245,391
$2,945,045
$3,179,710
$3,434,131
$3,709,297
$4,005,233
$7,336,345
$7,920,665
$8,557,278
$9,239,224
$9,977,573
$2,165,007
$2,339,587
$2,524,596
$2,726,949
$27,930,179
$30,168,659
Exhibit I-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
Combined 33.3% and 66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Composite
Number of Participants
Workers
Total
35,805
12,948
14,390
8,656
35,994
$112,828,716
$121,855,872
$131,604,858
$142,135,825
$153,504,629
$29,557,176
$31,921,999
$40,211,309
$35,330,328
$38,155,373
$41,208,355
$44,504,816
$48,065,478
$40,914,143
$44,186,111
$47,720,875
$51,539,209
$55,661,888
$105,801,647
$114,263,483
$123,405,611
$133,276,776
$143,938,675
$116,000,499
$125,286,853
$135,307,297
$146,129,097
$157,820,132
$30,452,679
$32,889,306
$35,519,614
$38,361,645
$41,430,082
$36,411,547
$39,324,627
$42,469,511
$45,867,853
$49,537,990
$41,965,846
$45,322,863
$48,948,506
$52,864,640
$57,094,197
$108,830,072
$117,536,796
$126,937,631
$137,094,138
$148,062,269
$10,440,583
$11,275,369
$12,441,317
$13,975,572
$36,857,472
$13,435,527
$15,093,192
$39,804,088
$12,177,662
$14,511,829
$16,300,222
$42,989,713
$13,152,402
$15,672,046
$16,925,299
$17,604,112
$19,012,312
$46,428,560
$11,112,235
$12,000,236
$13,301,215
$33,677,651
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$34,476,381
$37,232,751
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$39,296,068
Year 2
$42,443,166
Year 3
$45,837,183
Year 4
$49,505,055
Year 5
$53,464,741
$14,204,528
$50,142,139
Employer Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$35,920,211
$38,796,947
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$48,871,678
$9,264,201
$10,004,928
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$12,604,047
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
Exhibit I-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
Combined33,3% and 66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Composite
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
$40,784,220
$10,747,895
$12,857,995
Year 2
$44,046,740
$11,609,009
$13,888,864
Year 3
$47,570,724
$12,536,396
Year 4
$51,371,880
$55,483,713
Year 5
$13,538,775
$14,621,507
$14,996,123
$16,197,975
$17,495,489
$14,689,059
$15,864,764
$17,134,589
$18,505,859
$19,986,965
$48,242,609
$52,103,961
($895,503)
($967,307)
($1,043,233)
($1,128,894)
($1,218,773)
($1,081,219)
($1,169,254)
($1,261,156)
($1,363,037)
($1,472,512)
($1,051,703)
($1,136,752)
($1,227,631)
($1,325,431)
($1,432,309)
($3,028,425)
($3,273,313)
($3,532,020)
($3,817,362)
($4,123,594)
$38,294,949
$41,362,637
$44,667,108
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
($3,171,783)
($3,430,981)
($3,702,439)
($3,993,272)
($4,315,503)
Exhibit II-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
33.3% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Number of Participants
Workers
34,198
12,175
13,578
8,442
34,195
$107,764,738
$116,386,737
$125,698,169
$135,756,485
$146,615,034
$27,792,603
$33,336,706
$30,016,245
$36,002,339
$32,418,129
$35,009,943
$37,810,680
$38,883,047
$41,993,495
$45,353,236
$39,902,633
$43,093,709
$46,541,084
$50,265,019
$54,285,774
$101,031,942
$109,112,293
$117,842,260
$127,268,457
$137,449,690
$27,114,699
$32,523,655
$35,125,743
$37,934,760
$40,970,257
$44,248,530
$38,929,101
$42,043,186
$45,406,479
$49,039,240
$52,962,744
$98,567,455
$11,112,235
$13,301,215
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$105,134,227
$113,551,039
$122,632,660
$132,440,646
$143,036,555
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$35,920,211
Year 2
$38,796,947
Year 3
$41,899,390
Year 4
$45,252,162
Year 5
$48,871,678
$29,284,284
$31,626,267
$34,156,719
$36,888,789
$9,264,201
$10,004,928
$10,805,556
$12,000,236
$12,604,047
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$11,670,468
$106,453,213
$114,967,506
$124,166,216
$134,100,063
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Employer Contribution
Year 1
$35,920,211
$9,264,201
$11,112,235
Year 2
$10,004,928
Year 4
$38,796,947
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$11,670,468
Year 5
$48,871,678
$12,604,047
$12,000,236
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
Year 3
$10,805,556
$13,301,215
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Exhibit II-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
33.3% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$33,293,805
$35,957,145
$38,833,880
$41,936,322
$45,293,199
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
$2,630,511
Year 2
$2,835,698
Year 3
$3,065,509
Year 4
$3,315,839
Year 5
$3,578,479
$8,586,297
$10,299,185
$12,326,671
$31,212,153
$9,274,428
$11,125,271
$13,313,372
$10,015,155
$10,815,783
$11,680,695
$12,011,642
$12,974,593
$14,014,126
$14,379,089
$15,529,902
$16,772,904
$33,713,071
$36,405,886
$39,320,278
$42,467,725
$677,904
$813,051
$973,532
$731,961
$876,596
$948,287
$1,023,238
$1,104,706
$1,050,523
$791,862
$853,224
$921,891
$1,134,605
$1,225,779
$1,323,030
$2,464,487
$2,659,080
$2,874,754
$3,102,241
$3,349,627
Exhibit II-B
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
J3.J% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Number of Participants
Workers
34,198
12,175
13,578
8,442
34,195
Year 1
$107,764,738
$27,792,603
$116,386,737
$30,016,245
$33,336,706
$36,002,339
$39,902,633
Year 2
$43,093,709
$101,031,942
$109,112,293
Year 3
$125,698,169
$135,756,485
$146,615,034
$32,418,129
$38,883,047
$46,541,084
$117,842,260
$35,009,943
$41,993,495
$45,353,236
$50,265,019
$127,268,457
$54,285,774
$137,449,690
$32,523,655
$38,929,101
$35,125,743
$42,043,186
$45,406,479
$98,567,455
$106,453,213
$114,967,506
Total Premium Rates
Year 4
Year 5
$37,810,680
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
$105,134,227
Year 2
$113,551,039
$27,114,699
$29,284,284
Year 3
$122,632,660
$31,626,267
Year 4
$132,440,646
$34,156,719
Year 5
$143,036,555
$36,888,789
$37,934,760
$40,970,257
$44,248,530
$49,039,240
$52,962,744
$124,166,216
$134,100,063
$11,112,235
$13,301,215
$33,677,651
$12,000,236
$14,364,907
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$35,920,211
Year 2
$38,796,947
$9,264,201
$10,004,928
Year 3
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$12,961,559
$15,513,695
Year 4
$13,997,832
$16,754,669
Year 5
$48,871,678
$12,604,047
$15,117,202
$18,094,920
$13,301,215
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
Employer Contribution
Year 1
$35,920,211
$9,264,201
$11,112,235
Year 2
$38,796,947
$10,004,928
$12,000,236
Year 3
$41,899,390
$12,961,559
Year 4
$45,252,162
$48,871,678
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$12,604,047
Year 5
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Exhibit II-B
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
33.3% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
$28,037,094
$30,279,593
$32,702,247
$35,314,290
$38,141,371
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
$7,887,222
Year 2
$8,513,250
Year 3
$9,197,142
Year 4
$9,937,871
Year 5
$10,730,307
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$7,230,562
$8,673,002
$7,810,214
$9,107,947
$9,836,256
$9,368,984
$10,114,904
$10,926,080
$11,801,700
$2,033,639
$2,196,175
$2,373,175
$2,561,060
$2,766,330
$2,439,234
$2,632,883
$2,845,025
$3,071,751
$3,317,132
$8,433,842
$10,380,216
$11,211,213
$12,108,765
$13,077,940
$14,124,767
$26,283,780
$28,390,411
$30,657,511
$33,111,967
$35,762,723
$2,919,987
$7,392,860
$3,152,682
$3,404,929
$3,677,741
$3,971,167
$7,981,740
$8,623,129
$9,310,552
$10,054,629
Exhibit 11-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
33.3% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Number of Participants
Workers
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
34,198
12,175
13,578
8,442
34,195
$107,764,738
$1 16,386,737
$125,698,169
$135,756,485
$146,615,034
$27,792,603
$33,336,706
$36,002,339
$39,902,633
$43,093,709
$101,031,942
$38,883,047
$117,842,260
$127,268,457
$37,810,680
$41,993,495
$45,353,236
$46,541,084
$50,265,019
$54,285,774
$137,449,690
$27,114,699
$32,523,655
$38,929,101
$98,567,455
$29,284,284
$35,125,743
$42,043,186
$106,453,213
$114,967,506
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$30,016,245
$32,418,129
$35,009,943
$109,112,293
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$105,134,227
$113,551,039
$122,632,660
$132,440,646
$143,036,555
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$35,920,211
Year 2
$38,796,947
Year 3
$41,899,390
Year 4
$45,252,162
Year 5
$48,871,678
$31,626,267
$37,934,760
$34,156,719
$40,970,257
$36,888,789
$44,248,530
$45,406,479
$49,039,240
$52,962,744
$9,264,201
$11,112,235
$13,301,215
$33,677,651
$10,004,928
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$16,754,669
$42,422,969
$12,604,047
$12,000,236
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$18,094,920
$45,816,169
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$124,166,216
$134,100,063
Employer Contribution
Year 1
$35,920,211
$9,264,201
$11,112,235
$13,301,215
Year 2
$38,796,947
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$48,871,678
$10,004,928
$12,000,236
$14,364,907
$10,805,556
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$11,670,468
$12,604,047
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Exhibit II-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
33,3% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$38,550,516
$41,634,697
$44,965,513
$48,558,354
$52,445,027
$9,942,032
$12,523,619
$13,525,134
$11,925,368
$12,881,558
$13,908,380
$15,023,106
$16,226,553
$14,273,126
$15,415,531
$16,649,413
$17,981,864
$19,421,041
$45,528,589
$49,172,728
($677,831)
($732,253)
($789,451)
($854,612)
($922,548)
($813,132)
($879,691)
($948,451)
($1,025,275)
($1,107,721)
($972,923)
($1,051,636)
($1,135,719)
($1,226,183)
($1,325,107)
($2,463,886)
($2,663,580)
($2,873,621)
($3,106,070)
($3,355,376)
$10,738,642
$11,596,468
$36,140,526
$39,035,731
$42,154,261
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
($2,626,200)
($2,841,854)
($3,066,124)
($3,306,193)
($3,573,349)
Exhibit III-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Number of Participants
Workers
1,607
773
812
214
1,799
$5,063,978
$5,469,135
$1,764,573
$1,993,622
$1,011,510
$4,769,705
$1,905,754
Year 4
$5,906,689
$6,379,340
$2,058,252
$2,222,808
$2,153,034
$2,325,308
$2,511,321
$1,092,402
$1,179,791
$1,274,190
$5,151,190
$5,563,351
$6,008,319
Year 5
$6,889,595
$2,400,629
$2,712,242
$1,376,114
$6,488,985
$5,342,439
$5,769,773
$1,887,852
$2,154,009
$2,326,283
$1,038,371
$1,121,446
$1,211,146
$1,308,036
$1,412,682
$5,080,232
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
$2,038,865
Year 4
$6,231,432
$6,729,923
Year 5
$7,268,332
$2,378,181
$2,568,432
Year 2
$3,375,857
$3,646,219
$1,176,382
$1,270,441
Year 3
$3,937,793
Year 4
$4,252,893
$1,372,106
$1,481,934
Year 5
$4,593,063
$1,600,481
Year 1
$0
Year 2
$2,201,937
$2,512,393
$2,713,412
$2,930,508
$5,486,594
$5,925,476
$6,399,629
$6,911,622
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$1,329,082
$1,435,291
$1,550,270
$674,357
$3,179,821
$3,434,017
$1,808,097
$728,285
$786,527
$849,443
$917,392
$4,325,970
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 3
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 4
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 5
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$1,674,214
$3,708,903
$4,005,591
Employer Contribution
Exhibit III-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
$1,966,582
$711,470
$824,927
$364,014
$1,900,411
Year 2
$2,123,554
$2,477,030
$896,247
Year 5
$2,675,269
$967,951
$424,619
$458,593
$495,290
$2,216,573
Year 4
$890,992
$962,123
$1,039,198
$1,122,411
$2,052,577
$2,293,639
$768,424
$829,831
$393,161
Year 3
$2,585,652
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
($278,461)
Year 2
($300,638)
Year 3
($324,743)
Year 4
($350,583)
Year 5
($378,737)
($123,279)
($133,111)
($143,685)
($155,373)
($167,803)
($160,387)
($173,249)
($187,085)
($202,091)
($218,266)
($26,861)
($29,044)
($31,355)
($33,846)
($36,568)
($310,527)
($335,404)
($362,125)
($391,310)
($422,637)
$2,394,038
Exhibit Ill-B
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Number of Participants
Workers
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
1,607
773
812
214
1,799
Year 1
$5,063,978
$1,764,573
Year 2
$5,469,135
$1,905,754
$1,993,622
$2,153,034
$1,011,510
$1,092,402
$4,769,705
$5,151,190
Year 3
$5,906,689
Year 4
$6,379,340
$2,325,308
$2,511,321
$1,179,791
$1,274,190
$5,563,351
$6,008,319
Year 5
$6,889,595
$2,058,252
$2,222,808
$2,400,629
$2,712,242
$1,376,114
$6,488,985
Year 1
$5,342,439
$1,887,852
$1,038,371
$5,080,232
Year 2
$5,769,773
$6,231,432
$6,729,923
$7,268,332
$2,038,865
$2,201,937
$1,121,446
$5,486,594
$5,925,476
Year 1
Year 2
Total Premium Rates
Total Plan Cost
$2,378,181
$2,568,432
$2,154,009
$2,326,283
$2,512,393
$2,713,412
$2,930,508
$1,412,682
$6,911,622
$3,375,857
$1,176,382
$1,329,082
$674,357
$3,179,821
$3,646,219
$3,937,793
$1,270,441
$1,435,291
$728,285
Year 3
$1,372,106
$1,550,270
$786,527
$3,434,017
$3,708,903
Year 4
$4,252,893
$1,481,934
$1,674,214
$849,443
$4,005,591
Year 5
$4,593,063
$1,600,481
$1,808,097
$917,392
$4,325,970
Year 1
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 2
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 3
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 4
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 5
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$1,211,146
$1,308,036
$6,399,629
Employee Contributions
Employer Contribution
Exhibit III-B
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
$1,699,460
$1,835,065
$1,982,067
$2,140,534
$2,311,852
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
($11,339)
Year 2
($12,149)
Year 3
($13,171)
Year 4
($14,087)
Year 5
($15,320)
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$617,077
$717,227
$312,095
$1,646,399
$666,481
$774,678
$719,734
$777,338
$839,529
$836,503
$903,527
$975,886
$337,089
$364,062
$393,191
$424,656
$1,778,248
$1,920,299
$2,074,056
$2,240,071
($28,886)
($31,168)
($33,588)
($36,464)
($39,381)
($52,687)
($56,935)
($61,465)
($66,420)
($71,741)
$25,058
$27,028
($56,515)
($61,075)
($65,851)
($71,328)
($77,056)
$29,202
$31,556
$34,066
Exhibit III-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Number of Participants
Workers
1,607
773
812
214
1,799
$5,063,978
$5,469,135
$1,764,573
$1,905,754
Year 4
$5,906,689
$6,379,340
$2,058,252
$2,222,808
$1,011,510
$1,092,402
$1,179,791
$1,274,190
$4,769,705
$5,151,190
$5,563,351
$6,008,319
Year 5
$6,889,595
$2,400,629
$1,993,622
$2,153,034
$2,325,308
$2,511,321
$2,712,242
$1,376,114
$6,488,985
Year 1
$5,342,439
$1,887,852
$1,038,371
Year 2
$2,038,865
$2,201,937
$5,080,232
$5,486,594
Year 4
$5,769,773
$6,231,432
$6,729,923
Year 5
$7,268,332
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Total Plan Cost
Year 3
$2,378,181
$2,568,432
$2,154,009
$2,326,283
$2,512,393
$2,713,412
$2,930,508
$1,329,082
$1,435,291
$1,550,270
$1,674,214
$1,808,097
$917,392
$3,179,821
$3,434,017
$3,708,903
$4,005,591
$4,325,970
$1,121,446
$1,211,146
$1,308,036
$1,412,682
$5,925,476
$6,399,629
$6,911,622
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$3,375,857
Year 2
$3,646,219
Year 3
$3,937,793
Year 4
$4,252,893
Year 5
$4,593,063
$1,176,382
$1,270,441
$1,372,106
$1,481,934
$1,600,481
Year 1
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 2
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 3
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 4
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 5
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$674,357
$728,285
$786,527
$849,443
Employer Contribution
Exhibit IIl-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
$805,863
$932,627
$415,933
$2,154,423
Year 2
$2,233,704
$2,412,043
$870,367
$1,007,306
$449,233
Year 3
$2,605,211
$939,928
$1,087,743
$485,176
$2,326,906
$2,512,847
Year 4
:
$2,813,526
:
$3,038,686
$1,015,156
$523,995
$1,096,373
$1,174,869
$1,268,936
$565,924
$2,714,020
$2,931,233
($217,672)
($235,054)
($253,782)
($274,282)
($296,225)
($268,087)
($289,563)
($312,705)
($337,762)
($364,791)
($78,780)
($85,116)
($91,912)
($99,248)
($107,202)
($564,539)
($609,733)
($658,399)
($711,292)
($768,218)
Year 5
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
($545,583)
($589,127)
($636,315)
($687,079)
($742,154)
Exhibit IV
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Census Assumptions Used in Analysis
PARTICIPATION ASSUMPTIONS
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Total Eligible
48,000
15,000
17,000
16,000
48,000
33.3% Contribution
34,198
12,175
13,578
8,442
34,195
66.7% Contribution
1,607
773
812
214
1,799
35,805
12,948
14,390
8,656
35,994
Total Participating
Exhibit V
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Participation Based Premiums Per Month
Recom’d
Participation Level
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
Rates
Premium Rate
Composite
$229.12 $235.99 $242.87 $257.68 $268.97 $274.53 $287.11
$262.60
Under 25
$175.58 $180.85 $186.11 $197.46 $206.11 $210.38 $220.02
$190.23
25-39
$188.31
$193.96 $199.61 $211.78 $221.06 $225.63 $235.97
$204.60
40-64
$322.68 $332.36 $342.04 $362.90 $378.80 $386.63 $404.35
$393.89
Exhibit VI
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Monthly Contributions at Various Participation Levels
Recom'd
Participation Level
Cont % Category
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
Rates
33.3% Contribution
Under 25
$58.53
$60.28
$62.04
$65.82
$68.70
$70.13
$73.34
$63.41
25-39
$62.77
$64.65
$66.54
$70.59
$73.69
$75.21
$78.66
$68.20
$120.97 $126.27 $128.88 $134.78
$131.30
40-64
Composite
$107.56 $110.79 $114.01
$76.37
$78.66
$80.96
$85.89
$89.66
$91.51
$95.70
$87.53
Under 25
$1 17.06 $120.56 $124.08 $131.64 $137.40 $140.26 $146.68
$126.82
25-39
$125.54 $129.30 $133.08 $141.18 $147.38 $150.42 $157.32
$136.40
40-64
$215.12 $221.58 $228.02 $241.94 $252.54 $257.76 $269.56
$262.60
Composite
$152.74 $157.32 $161.92 $171.78 $179.32 $183.02 $191.40
$175.06
66.7% Contribution
Exhibit VII
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Base Cost Assumptions
Frequency
per 1000
Members
Average
Per Capita
Monthly
Charge
Claims Cost
Frequency
Amount
of per
of per
Per Capita
Monthly
Per Capita
Monthly
Service
Service
Cost Sharing
Claims Cost
Copay
Copay
Value
After Copav
Hospital Inpatient
Non-Maternity
Medical
135
$1,279.63
$14.40
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$14.40
Surgical
142
$2,329.16
$27.46
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$27.46
Neonatal
21
$4,658.33
$8.32
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$8.32
Psychiatric
76
$1,215.65
$7.71
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$7.71
Alcohol & Drug Abuse
41
$972.52
$3.30
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$3.30
Maternity
Normal Deliveries
20
$1,192.15
$2.02
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$2.02
Cesarean Deliveries
19
$1,943.91
$3.13
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$3.13
Non-Deliveries
11
$1,324.19
$1.26
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1.26
5
$883.39
$0.39
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.39
Abortions
Boarder Babies
19
$395.06
$0,64
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.64
Skilled Nursing Facility
12
$214.90
$0.21
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.21
Total Hospital Inpatient
502
$1,644.61
$68.85
$0.00
$68.85
Hospital Outpatient
Emergency Room
364
$182.25
$5.53
364.4
$25,00
$0.76
$4.77
Medical
139
$108.77
$1.26
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1,26
Surgery
Radiology
103
$718.00
$6.18
0.0
$0.00
$0,00
$6.18
170
$240.15
$3.40
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$3.40
Pathology
184
$72.36
$1.11
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1.11
Other Services
253
$145.43
$3.07
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$3,07
Maternity Non-Deliveries
7
$210.90
$0.13
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.13
Total Hospital Outpatient
1,221
$203.26
$20.68
$0.76
$19.92
106
$624.82
$5.53
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$5.53
14
$124.96
$0.15
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.15
68
$109.90
$0.63
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.63
$2.02
Physician
Inpatient Surgery
Primary Surgeon
Assistant Surgeon
Anesthesia
Outpatient Surgery
86
$282.99
$2.02
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
Surgical Center
1 16
$239.72
$2.31
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$2.31
Office
253
$125.01
$2.64
0.0
$0,00
$0.00
$2.64
53
$88.71
$0.39
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0,39
OP Hospital
Anesthesia
Maternity
Normal Deliveries
6
$484.84
$0.26
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.26
Cesarean Deliveries
3
$1,126.14
$0.25
0,0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.25
Non-Deliveries
5
$196.33
$0.09
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.09
409
$154.71
$5.27
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$5.27
6
$105.52
$0.05
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.05
$200.28
$0.31
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.31
Inpatient Visits
Hospital Visits
Extended Care Visits
Critical Care Visits
Exhibit VII
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Base Cost Assumptions
Frequency
Amount
Per Capita
of per
of per
Monthly
Per Capita
Monthly
Average
Per Capita
Monthly
Service
Service
Cost Sharing
Claims Cost
Charge
Claims Cost
Copay
Copay
Value
After Copay
5.251
$57.04
$24.96
5,250.6
$5.00
$2.19
$22.77
2
$89.13
$0.01
1.6
$5.00
$0.00
$0.01
Therapeutic Injections
Allergy Testing
129
$70.34
$0.75
128.8
$5.00
$0.05
$0.70
26
$39.93
$0.09
25.9
$5.00
$0.01
$0.08
Allergy Immunotherapy
Diagnostic Testing
239
$10.51
$0.21
239.4
$5.00
$0.10
$0.11
79
$74.07
$0.49
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.49
Frequency
per 1000
Members
Office Visits
Home Visits
Physician (Continued)
Office Visits & Misc. Services
Emergency Room Visits
316
$140.44
$3.70
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$3.70
Consultations
106
$142.01
$1.26
106.1
$5.00
$0.04
$1.21
Physical Medicine
334
$30.51
$0.85
333.9
$5.00
$0.14
$0.71
Occupational Therapy
Speech Therapy
Chiropractor
Urgent Care
276
$47.93
$1.10
275.9
$5.00
$0.1 1
$0.99
10
$93.03
$0.07
9.6
$5.00
$0.00
$0.07
0
$26.61
$0.00
0.0
$5.00
$0.00
$0.00
1,155
$98.31
$9.46
1,155.0
$5.00
$0.48
$8.98
Total Physician
9,066
$81.29
$62.84
$3.14
$59.71
Radiology
IP (Professional)
137
$67.53
$0.77
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.77
OP (Professional)
337
$89.27
$2.51
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$2.51
Office (Combined)
494
$98.86
$4.07
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$4.07
MRI
3
$796.84
$0.20
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.20
CT-Scan
2
$479.85
$0.08
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.08
972
$93.99
$7.61
$0.00
$7.61
Total Radiology
Pathology
IP (Professional)
OP (Professional)
66
$21.19
$0.12
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.12
125
$32.95
$0.34
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.34
Office (Combined)
3,059
$35.77
$9.12
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$9.12
Total Pathology
3,250
$35.36
$9.58
$0.00
$9.58
$28.91
Other Services
9,170
$42.83
$32.73
9,170.1
$5.00
$3.82
PDN/Homc Health Care
32
$50.18
$0.13
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.13
Ambulance
15
$71.37
$0.09
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.09
Durable Medical Equipment
29
$103.13
$0.25
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.25
3
$318.54
$0.09
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.09
9,249
$43.18
$33,29
$3.82
$29.47
Prescription Drugs
Prosthetics
Total Other Services
Exhibit VII
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Base Cost Assumptions
Frequency
per 1000
Average
Per Capita
Monthly
Members
Charge
Claims Cost
Frequency
of per
Amount
Per Capita
Per Capita
of per
Service
Service
Monthly
Cost Sharing
Claims Cost
Conav
Copav
Value
After Copav
Monthly
Additional Services
Immunizations
Physical Exams
401
$35.79
$1.20
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1.20
94
$59.26
$0.46
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.46
Well Woman Exams
195
$59.26
$0.96
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.96
Vision Exams
262
$53.49
$1.17
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1.17
Speech Exams
210
$90.21
$1.58
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1.58
4
$62.31
$0.02
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.02
105
$264.81
$2.32
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$2.32
4
$45.89
$0.02
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.02
Abortions
4
$83.67
$0.03
4.3
$5.00
$0.00
$0.03
Podiatrist
60
$78.29
$0.39
60.1
$5.00
$0.03
$0.37
203
$162.49
$2.75
203.0
$5.00
$0.08
$2.66
30
$117.50
$0.30
30.2
$5.00
$0.01
$0.28
1,574
$85.35
$11.19
$0.12
$11.07
25,834
$99.47
$214.05
$7.84
$206.21
Hearing Exams
Hearing Aids
Family Planning
OP Psychiatric
OP Alcohol & Drug Abuse
Total Additional Setv'ices
Total All Services
Cost with Administrative Loading
$229.12
Small Group Insurance Program
Expected Cost Analysis
August 7,2006
Executive Summary
The objective of this analysis was to determine the expected monthly cost of providing medical
coverage in currently uninsured individuals who work for small employers - defined as
employers with less than 50 employees who do not currently provide health insurance. The
insurance would only be available to the employee; dependent coverage would not be offered.
Buck also modeled the impact of the baseline claim costs running 5% lower and 5% higher than
projected. These variations provide additional information on the likely volatility of the actual
experience under the program.
While there are approximately 48,000 individuals that could be covered under the plan, based on
the survey conducted by the Santa Clara Family Health Plan, not all of the members would
participate. We used to results of the survey and the contribution rates that were developed in
our analysis to determine the expected participation rates. Based on the survey, we expect
approximately 65% of the eligible employees to enroll.
The expected cost of the program on a per enrolled participant basis increases as the participation
percentage decreases. As enrollment decreases, the underlying risk characteristics of the enrolled
population increases. This means that typically, the healthier portion of a population is the first
to elect not to participate, which increases the expected cost for the remaining population.
Because of this risk, we recommend that the initial premium rates be set assuming that only 60%
of the eligible employees enroll. This assumption will produce premium rates that provide
additional margin to cover adverse experience.
Table 1 shows the recommended premium rates and participant contributions by age band
assuming that the participant contributes 1/3 of the cost(and the remaining 2/3 is split between
the health plans and the employer).
Table 1
Small Group Insurance Program
Rates Effective January 1, 2007
Participant
Recommended Contribution
Premium
33.33%
40-64
$190.23
$204.60
$393.89
$63.41
$68.20
$131.30
Composite
$262.60
$87.53
Under 25
25-39
The table shows that the monthly contribution for the eligible employees ranges from $63.41 to
$131.30 assuming the 1/3 contribution for both employees and employers. If the health plans
elect to go with composite rates instead of age banded rates, the contributions are $87.53 for both
the employee and the employer.
The remainder of this report provides more detail on the methods and assumptions used to
develop the final cost estimates.
2
Development of Cost Estimates
This section describes the methodology used to develop the recommended premium rates, the
expected total cost, participant contributions, and net health plan costs for the new benefit plans
for eligible employees. This program is intended to provide coverage to eligible small group
employers and their employees who do not have coverage and have income of less than 300% of
the federal poverty level.
The first step was the development of the expected cost and utilization experience of the
expansion population. We used Medi-Cal experience for the four county area and our
proprietary cost and utilization databases to develop the expected cost patterns for this
population. Our proprietary model is built from Medi-Cal data for the State of California,
supplemented by Medicaid experience in other western U.S. states, OSHPD hospital data for the
State of California, and other employer based data sources for the Western U.S.
This model allows us to develop the expected per member per month(PMPM)claim costs for
the eligible population. Since this is primarily an uninsured or under-insured population, we
developed adjustment to reflect the estimated impact of pent-up demand. Exhibit VII provides
the detailed expected cost and utilization experience used in the analysis. The exhibit shows the
expected utilization rates per 1,000 covered members and the expected cost per service for each
detailed benefit category. W based the projections on the assumption that the fee schedule used
to pay providers would be consistent with Medicare reimbursement rates.
It then shows the impact of any per service copayment amount and the net expected cost on a
PMPM basis. The resulting claim costs were then loaded by 10% to account for the expected
administrative cost of the program. Table 2 below summarizes the general benefit provisions
that were used to develop the expected plan costs. This is based on the IHSS program offered in
San Mateo County and the VSP vision plan provided by Santa Clara Family Health Plan.
Table 2
Small Group Insurance Program
Category
Benefit
Hospitalization
Outpatient
Emergency
Maternity
Prescription
Drugs
Covered.
Covered. $5 co-payment
Covered. $25 co-payment - waived if admitted.
Covered.
Covered. Limited formulary. $5 co-payment. $25 co-payment for
name brands with generic equivalents. 30 day supply.
3
The second step was to develop the expected eligible and participating population for the
program. The Santa Clara Family Health Plan provided this data. Based on this data, there are
approximately 14,000 eligible employees who could be covered under this plan. In addition, the
survey provided information on the likelihood the eligible employers would offer coverage and
the likelihood that employees would enroll in coverage based on the required member premium
contribution. We were requested to develop participant contribution rates of 1/3 of the premium
rates for the eligible employees. An additional 1/3 would be paid by the employer and the health
plans would subsidize the remaining 1/3. In addition, we assumed that if the employee lost their
employment they could continue the coverage if they paid both the employer and employee
portion, or 2/3 of the cost.
Based on the data provided, we estimate that approximately 71% of the 14,000 employees would
participate. In addition, we assumed that 10% of the participating employees would lose
coverage and of those, 50% would elect to continue coverage. This means that in total about
75% of the eligible population would participate in the program. The total expected enrollment
under the composite rating method and under the age based rating method is shown in Exhibit IV
for the two groups of eligible employees.
The third step in the analysis was to develop the expected premium costs based on participation
level. Exhibit IV shows the expected premium costs for the two contribution scenarios. It then
shows the expected cost as the participation level falls. As enrollment decreases, the underlying
risk characteristics of the enrolled population increases. This means that typically, the healthier
portion of a population is the first to elect not to participate, which increases the expected cost on
a PMPM basis for the remaining population.
Since the expected participation rate for the employees is approximately 71% of the eligible
employees, we recommend that the health plan set the rates at the 60% participation rate level to
provide some additional conservatism in the initial rates for the plan.
Exhibit VI shows the monthly cost share for the eligible employees for the various participation
levels and the recommended 60% participation rates. It shows the contribution rates by age
range and on a composite basis for the two contribution rate scenarios. The contribution rates for
the higher participation scenarios will never apply because it is unlikely that a high percentage of
the eligible employees will enroll. To help control the risk and provide a higher likelihood that
the premium rates will cover the cost of the plan, we recommend that the 60% participation level
be used to develop the premiums and contributions for the plan.
The final step was to develop the expected total premium income, total plan cost, and net health
plan costs as well as the costs if the baseline claim costs run 5% lower and 5% higher than
projected for the two premium contribution scenarios. These variations provide the health plans
additional information on the likely volatility of the actual experience under the program.
Exhibit I-A through I-C provide the detailed results for the composite and age based rate options
separately for the first five years of the program. It combines the results for the employees who
are paying 1/3 of the cost and those who are paying 2/3 of the cost. Exhibit I-A provides the
expected results and Exhibits 1-B and I-C provides the results for the two sensitivity analysis
scenarios.
4
The exhibits first show the estimated number of eligible employees who will elect coverage. It
then shows the total premium rate collection, the total expected plan cost, the participant
contributions, the employer contribution, and the net health plan cost for each year. The
premium rates are based on the 60% participation level, while the costs are based on the
expected cost for each health plan individually. Since we expect almost 71% of the eligible
employees to enroll under this scenario, the underlying risk is improved and the cost is expected
to be less than the premium cost.
The exhibits show that using the 60% participation rate as the basis for developing the premium
rates protects the program if costs are equal to expected or are less than expected. If costs are
5% higher than expected then the program runs a deficit. The recommended premium rates will
provide protection if actual costs are up to 2.2% higher than expected.
Exhibits II-A through II-C provide the detailed results for the first five years of the program for
the employees who are contributing 33.3% of the premium cost(and the employer and health
plan evenly split the other 2/3 of the premium cost). Exhibit II-A provides the expected results
and Exhibits II-B and II-C provides the results for the two sensitivity analysis scenarios.
The exhibits first show the estimated number of eligible employees who will elect coverage for
each participating health plan. It then shows the total premium rate collection, the total expected
plan cost, the participant contributions, the employer contribution, and the net health plan cost
for each year. The premium rates are based on the 60% participation level, while the costs are
based on the expected cost for each contribution scenario. Since we expect almost 71% of the
eligible employees to enroll under this scenario, the underlying risk is slightly improved, so the
cost is expected to be less than the premium cost.
The exhibits show that using the 60% participation rate as the basis for developing the premium
rates protects the program if costs are equal to expected or are less than expected. If costs are
5% higher than expected then the program runs a deficit. The recommended premium rates will
provide protection if actual costs are up to 2.5% higher than expected.
Exhibits III-A through III-C provide the detailed results for the first five years of the program for
the employees who are contributing 66.7% of the premium cost. Exhibit III-A provides the
expected results and Exhibits III-B and III-C provides the results for the two sensitivity analysis
scenarios.
The exhibits first show the estimated number of eligible employees who will elect coverage for
each participating health plan. It then shows the total premium rate collection, the total expected
plan cost, the participant contributions, the employer contribution, and the net health plan cost
for each year. The premium rates are based on the 60% participation level, while the costs are
based on the expected cost for each contribution scenario. These individuals are likely to be
higher risk, so the exhibit shows that the premiums are not likely to cover the expected costs
under any of the three sensitivity scenarios.
5
The exhibits show that these individuals will create a loss of approximately 5.5% to 6.5% of the
premium rates depending on whether the age based or composite rates are used. If their
experience is 5% better than expected these losses fall to 0.2% to 1.2%. If costs are 5% higher
than expected then the deficit increases to 10.8% to 11.8%. The expected high utilization of this
population is one of the key reasons to set the premium rates conservatively yet not so
conservative as to discourage enrollment in the program.
For Exhibit I, Exhibit II, and Exhibit III the premium rates, plan costs, and participant
contributions are assumed to increase 8% per year.
6
Exhibit I-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
Combined33.3% and 66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Composite
Number of Participants
Workers
Total
35,805
12,948
14,390
8,656
35,994
Year 1
$112,828,716
$29,557,176
$105,801,647
$121,855,872
$131,604,858
$142,135,825
$153,504,629
$31,921,999
$34,476,381
$37,232,751
$40,211,309
$35,330,328
$38,155,373
$40,914,143
Year 2
$44,186,111
$41,208,355
$44,504,816
$48,065,478
$47,720,875
$51,539,209
$55,661,888
$114,263,483
$123,405,611
$133,276,776
$143,938,675
$110,476,666
$119,320,812
$29,002,551
$31,323,149
$33,828,204
$34,677,664
$37,452,026
$39,967,472
$43,164,632
$40,447,153
$46,617,625
$103,647,687
$111,939,807
$120,892,982
$36,534,900
$39,457,221
$43,683,669
$47,179,038
$50,347,276
$130,565,845
$54,375,426
$141,011,685
$10,440,583
$12,441,317
$11,275,369
$14,204,528
$13,435,527
$14,511,829
$15,672,046
$16,925,299
$13,975,572
$15,093,192
$16,300,222
$17,604,112
$19,012,312
$36,857,472
$39,804,088
$42,989,713
$46,428,560
$50,142,139
$9,264,201
$10,004,928
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$12,604,047
$11,112,235
$12,000,236
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$13,301,215
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Total Premium Rates
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
$128,864,092
$139,170,569
Year 5
$150,304,887
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$39,296,068
Year 2
$42,443,166
Year 3
$45,837,183
Year 4
$49,505,055
Year 5
$53,464,741
$12,177,662
$13,152,402
Employer Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$35,920,211
$38,796,947
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$48,871,678
Exhibit I-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
Combined 33.3% and 66.67%) Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$35,260,387
$38,080,699
$41,127,519
$44,413,352
$47,968,468
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
$2,352,050
Year 2
$2,535,060
Year 3
$2,740,766
Year 4
$2,965,256
Year 5
$3,199,742
$9,297,767
$10,042,852
$10,844,986
$11,712,030
$12,648,646
$554,625
$652,664
$598,850
$648,177
$703,347
$761,202
$697,851
$754,088
$821,147
$886,440
$11,124,112
$12,690,685
$12,016,263
$13,706,533
$12,973,765
$14,013,791
$15,136,537
$14,803,708
$15,988,495
$17,268,194
$33,112,564
$35,765,648
$38,622,459
$41,714,316
$45,053,377
$946,671
$1,021,479
$2,153,960
$1,103,250
$2,512,629
$1,191,933
$2,710,931
$2,926,990
$1,286,462
$2,323,676
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
Exhibit I-B
Combined 33.3% and 66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Number of Participants
Workers
35,805
12,948
14,390
8,656
35,994
$112,828,716
$121,855,872
$131,604,858
$142,135,825
$153,504,629
$29,557,176
$31,921,999
$34,476,381
$37,232,751
$40,211,309
$35,330,328
$38,155,373
$41,208,355
$44,504,816
$48,065,478
$40,914,143
$44,186,111
$47,720,875
$51,539,209
$55,661,888
$105,801,647
$114,263,483
$123,405,611
$133,276,776
$143,938,675
$104,952,833
$113,354,771
$122,420,887
$132,212,041
$142,789,642
$27,552,423
$29,756,992
$32,943,781
$35,579,425
$38,424,795
$41,499,485
$44,820,087
$37,969,098
$41,006,401
$44,286,744
$47,829,912
$51,656,655
$98,465,302
$12,441,317
$13,975,572
$15,093,192
$16,300,222
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$39,296,068
Year 2
$42,443,166
Year 3
$45,837,183
Year 4
$49,505,055
Year 5
$53,464,741
$32,136,794
$34,708,155
$37,484,360
$10,440,583
$11,275,369
$12,177,662
$13,152,402
$14,204,528
$13,435,527
$14,511,829
$15,672,046
$16,925,299
$17,604,112
$19,012,312
$9,264,201
$10,004,928
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$12,604,047
$11,112,235
$12,000,236
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$13,301,215
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
$106,342,818
$114,848,333
$124,037,552
$133,961,102
$36,857,472
$39,804,088
$42,989,713
$46,428,560
$50,142,139
Employer Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$35,920,211
$38,796,947
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$48,871,678
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
Exhibit I-B
Combined 33.3% and 66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$29,736,554
$32,114,658
$34,684,314
$37,454,824
$40,453,223
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
$7,875,883
Year 2
$8,501,101
Year 3
$9,183,971
Year 4
$9,923,784
Year 5
$10,714,987
$7,847,639
$8,476,695
$9,153,576
$9,885,285
$10,675,785
$9,390,229
$10,143,662
$10,951,407
$11,829,607
$12,777,586
$10,692,311
$11,548,302
$12,472,827
$13,471,131
$14,549,423
$32,577,810
$35,186,023
$38,002,794
$2,004,753
$2,386,547
$2,575,948
$2,783,560
$3,005,331
$3,245,391
$2,945,045
$3,179,710
$3,434,131
$3,709,297
$4,005,233
$7,336,345
$7,920,665
$8,557,278
$9,239,224
$9,977,573
$2,165,007
$2,339,587
$2,524,596
$2,726,949
$27,930,179
$30,168,659
Exhibit I-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
Combined 33.3% and 66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Composite
Number of Participants
Workers
Total
35,805
12,948
14,390
8,656
35,994
$112,828,716
$121,855,872
$131,604,858
$142,135,825
$153,504,629
$29,557,176
$31,921,999
$40,211,309
$35,330,328
$38,155,373
$41,208,355
$44,504,816
$48,065,478
$40,914,143
$44,186,111
$47,720,875
$51,539,209
$55,661,888
$105,801,647
$114,263,483
$123,405,611
$133,276,776
$143,938,675
$116,000,499
$125,286,853
$135,307,297
$146,129,097
$157,820,132
$30,452,679
$32,889,306
$35,519,614
$38,361,645
$41,430,082
$36,411,547
$39,324,627
$42,469,511
$45,867,853
$49,537,990
$41,965,846
$45,322,863
$48,948,506
$52,864,640
$57,094,197
$108,830,072
$117,536,796
$126,937,631
$137,094,138
$148,062,269
$10,440,583
$11,275,369
$12,441,317
$13,975,572
$36,857,472
$13,435,527
$15,093,192
$39,804,088
$12,177,662
$14,511,829
$16,300,222
$42,989,713
$13,152,402
$15,672,046
$16,925,299
$17,604,112
$19,012,312
$46,428,560
$11,112,235
$12,000,236
$13,301,215
$33,677,651
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$34,476,381
$37,232,751
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$39,296,068
Year 2
$42,443,166
Year 3
$45,837,183
Year 4
$49,505,055
Year 5
$53,464,741
$14,204,528
$50,142,139
Employer Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$35,920,211
$38,796,947
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$48,871,678
$9,264,201
$10,004,928
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$12,604,047
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
Exhibit I-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
Combined33,3% and 66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Composite
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
$40,784,220
$10,747,895
$12,857,995
Year 2
$44,046,740
$11,609,009
$13,888,864
Year 3
$47,570,724
$12,536,396
Year 4
$51,371,880
$55,483,713
Year 5
$13,538,775
$14,621,507
$14,996,123
$16,197,975
$17,495,489
$14,689,059
$15,864,764
$17,134,589
$18,505,859
$19,986,965
$48,242,609
$52,103,961
($895,503)
($967,307)
($1,043,233)
($1,128,894)
($1,218,773)
($1,081,219)
($1,169,254)
($1,261,156)
($1,363,037)
($1,472,512)
($1,051,703)
($1,136,752)
($1,227,631)
($1,325,431)
($1,432,309)
($3,028,425)
($3,273,313)
($3,532,020)
($3,817,362)
($4,123,594)
$38,294,949
$41,362,637
$44,667,108
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
($3,171,783)
($3,430,981)
($3,702,439)
($3,993,272)
($4,315,503)
Exhibit II-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
33.3% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Number of Participants
Workers
34,198
12,175
13,578
8,442
34,195
$107,764,738
$116,386,737
$125,698,169
$135,756,485
$146,615,034
$27,792,603
$33,336,706
$30,016,245
$36,002,339
$32,418,129
$35,009,943
$37,810,680
$38,883,047
$41,993,495
$45,353,236
$39,902,633
$43,093,709
$46,541,084
$50,265,019
$54,285,774
$101,031,942
$109,112,293
$117,842,260
$127,268,457
$137,449,690
$27,114,699
$32,523,655
$35,125,743
$37,934,760
$40,970,257
$44,248,530
$38,929,101
$42,043,186
$45,406,479
$49,039,240
$52,962,744
$98,567,455
$11,112,235
$13,301,215
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$105,134,227
$113,551,039
$122,632,660
$132,440,646
$143,036,555
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$35,920,211
Year 2
$38,796,947
Year 3
$41,899,390
Year 4
$45,252,162
Year 5
$48,871,678
$29,284,284
$31,626,267
$34,156,719
$36,888,789
$9,264,201
$10,004,928
$10,805,556
$12,000,236
$12,604,047
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$11,670,468
$106,453,213
$114,967,506
$124,166,216
$134,100,063
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Employer Contribution
Year 1
$35,920,211
$9,264,201
$11,112,235
Year 2
$10,004,928
Year 4
$38,796,947
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$11,670,468
Year 5
$48,871,678
$12,604,047
$12,000,236
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
Year 3
$10,805,556
$13,301,215
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Exhibit II-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
33.3% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$33,293,805
$35,957,145
$38,833,880
$41,936,322
$45,293,199
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
$2,630,511
Year 2
$2,835,698
Year 3
$3,065,509
Year 4
$3,315,839
Year 5
$3,578,479
$8,586,297
$10,299,185
$12,326,671
$31,212,153
$9,274,428
$11,125,271
$13,313,372
$10,015,155
$10,815,783
$11,680,695
$12,011,642
$12,974,593
$14,014,126
$14,379,089
$15,529,902
$16,772,904
$33,713,071
$36,405,886
$39,320,278
$42,467,725
$677,904
$813,051
$973,532
$731,961
$876,596
$948,287
$1,023,238
$1,104,706
$1,050,523
$791,862
$853,224
$921,891
$1,134,605
$1,225,779
$1,323,030
$2,464,487
$2,659,080
$2,874,754
$3,102,241
$3,349,627
Exhibit II-B
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
J3.J% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Number of Participants
Workers
34,198
12,175
13,578
8,442
34,195
Year 1
$107,764,738
$27,792,603
$116,386,737
$30,016,245
$33,336,706
$36,002,339
$39,902,633
Year 2
$43,093,709
$101,031,942
$109,112,293
Year 3
$125,698,169
$135,756,485
$146,615,034
$32,418,129
$38,883,047
$46,541,084
$117,842,260
$35,009,943
$41,993,495
$45,353,236
$50,265,019
$127,268,457
$54,285,774
$137,449,690
$32,523,655
$38,929,101
$35,125,743
$42,043,186
$45,406,479
$98,567,455
$106,453,213
$114,967,506
Total Premium Rates
Year 4
Year 5
$37,810,680
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
$105,134,227
Year 2
$113,551,039
$27,114,699
$29,284,284
Year 3
$122,632,660
$31,626,267
Year 4
$132,440,646
$34,156,719
Year 5
$143,036,555
$36,888,789
$37,934,760
$40,970,257
$44,248,530
$49,039,240
$52,962,744
$124,166,216
$134,100,063
$11,112,235
$13,301,215
$33,677,651
$12,000,236
$14,364,907
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$35,920,211
Year 2
$38,796,947
$9,264,201
$10,004,928
Year 3
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$12,961,559
$15,513,695
Year 4
$13,997,832
$16,754,669
Year 5
$48,871,678
$12,604,047
$15,117,202
$18,094,920
$13,301,215
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
Employer Contribution
Year 1
$35,920,211
$9,264,201
$11,112,235
Year 2
$38,796,947
$10,004,928
$12,000,236
Year 3
$41,899,390
$12,961,559
Year 4
$45,252,162
$48,871,678
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$12,604,047
Year 5
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Exhibit II-B
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
33.3% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
$28,037,094
$30,279,593
$32,702,247
$35,314,290
$38,141,371
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
$7,887,222
Year 2
$8,513,250
Year 3
$9,197,142
Year 4
$9,937,871
Year 5
$10,730,307
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$7,230,562
$8,673,002
$7,810,214
$9,107,947
$9,836,256
$9,368,984
$10,114,904
$10,926,080
$11,801,700
$2,033,639
$2,196,175
$2,373,175
$2,561,060
$2,766,330
$2,439,234
$2,632,883
$2,845,025
$3,071,751
$3,317,132
$8,433,842
$10,380,216
$11,211,213
$12,108,765
$13,077,940
$14,124,767
$26,283,780
$28,390,411
$30,657,511
$33,111,967
$35,762,723
$2,919,987
$7,392,860
$3,152,682
$3,404,929
$3,677,741
$3,971,167
$7,981,740
$8,623,129
$9,310,552
$10,054,629
Exhibit 11-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
33.3% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Number of Participants
Workers
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
34,198
12,175
13,578
8,442
34,195
$107,764,738
$1 16,386,737
$125,698,169
$135,756,485
$146,615,034
$27,792,603
$33,336,706
$36,002,339
$39,902,633
$43,093,709
$101,031,942
$38,883,047
$117,842,260
$127,268,457
$37,810,680
$41,993,495
$45,353,236
$46,541,084
$50,265,019
$54,285,774
$137,449,690
$27,114,699
$32,523,655
$38,929,101
$98,567,455
$29,284,284
$35,125,743
$42,043,186
$106,453,213
$114,967,506
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$30,016,245
$32,418,129
$35,009,943
$109,112,293
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$105,134,227
$113,551,039
$122,632,660
$132,440,646
$143,036,555
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$35,920,211
Year 2
$38,796,947
Year 3
$41,899,390
Year 4
$45,252,162
Year 5
$48,871,678
$31,626,267
$37,934,760
$34,156,719
$40,970,257
$36,888,789
$44,248,530
$45,406,479
$49,039,240
$52,962,744
$9,264,201
$11,112,235
$13,301,215
$33,677,651
$10,004,928
$14,364,907
$15,513,695
$36,370,071
$39,280,810
$16,754,669
$42,422,969
$12,604,047
$12,000,236
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$18,094,920
$45,816,169
$33,677,651
$36,370,071
$10,805,556
$11,670,468
$124,166,216
$134,100,063
Employer Contribution
Year 1
$35,920,211
$9,264,201
$11,112,235
$13,301,215
Year 2
$38,796,947
$41,899,390
$45,252,162
$48,871,678
$10,004,928
$12,000,236
$14,364,907
$10,805,556
$12,961,559
$13,997,832
$15,117,202
$15,513,695
$16,754,669
$18,094,920
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$11,670,468
$12,604,047
$39,280,810
$42,422,969
$45,816,169
Exhibit II-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
33,3% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$38,550,516
$41,634,697
$44,965,513
$48,558,354
$52,445,027
$9,942,032
$12,523,619
$13,525,134
$11,925,368
$12,881,558
$13,908,380
$15,023,106
$16,226,553
$14,273,126
$15,415,531
$16,649,413
$17,981,864
$19,421,041
$45,528,589
$49,172,728
($677,831)
($732,253)
($789,451)
($854,612)
($922,548)
($813,132)
($879,691)
($948,451)
($1,025,275)
($1,107,721)
($972,923)
($1,051,636)
($1,135,719)
($1,226,183)
($1,325,107)
($2,463,886)
($2,663,580)
($2,873,621)
($3,106,070)
($3,355,376)
$10,738,642
$11,596,468
$36,140,526
$39,035,731
$42,154,261
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
($2,626,200)
($2,841,854)
($3,066,124)
($3,306,193)
($3,573,349)
Exhibit III-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Number of Participants
Workers
1,607
773
812
214
1,799
$5,063,978
$5,469,135
$1,764,573
$1,993,622
$1,011,510
$4,769,705
$1,905,754
Year 4
$5,906,689
$6,379,340
$2,058,252
$2,222,808
$2,153,034
$2,325,308
$2,511,321
$1,092,402
$1,179,791
$1,274,190
$5,151,190
$5,563,351
$6,008,319
Year 5
$6,889,595
$2,400,629
$2,712,242
$1,376,114
$6,488,985
$5,342,439
$5,769,773
$1,887,852
$2,154,009
$2,326,283
$1,038,371
$1,121,446
$1,211,146
$1,308,036
$1,412,682
$5,080,232
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Total Plan Cost
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
$2,038,865
Year 4
$6,231,432
$6,729,923
Year 5
$7,268,332
$2,378,181
$2,568,432
Year 2
$3,375,857
$3,646,219
$1,176,382
$1,270,441
Year 3
$3,937,793
Year 4
$4,252,893
$1,372,106
$1,481,934
Year 5
$4,593,063
$1,600,481
Year 1
$0
Year 2
$2,201,937
$2,512,393
$2,713,412
$2,930,508
$5,486,594
$5,925,476
$6,399,629
$6,911,622
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$1,329,082
$1,435,291
$1,550,270
$674,357
$3,179,821
$3,434,017
$1,808,097
$728,285
$786,527
$849,443
$917,392
$4,325,970
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 3
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 4
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 5
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$1,674,214
$3,708,903
$4,005,591
Employer Contribution
Exhibit III-A
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost Equals Expected Cost
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
$1,966,582
$711,470
$824,927
$364,014
$1,900,411
Year 2
$2,123,554
$2,477,030
$896,247
Year 5
$2,675,269
$967,951
$424,619
$458,593
$495,290
$2,216,573
Year 4
$890,992
$962,123
$1,039,198
$1,122,411
$2,052,577
$2,293,639
$768,424
$829,831
$393,161
Year 3
$2,585,652
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
($278,461)
Year 2
($300,638)
Year 3
($324,743)
Year 4
($350,583)
Year 5
($378,737)
($123,279)
($133,111)
($143,685)
($155,373)
($167,803)
($160,387)
($173,249)
($187,085)
($202,091)
($218,266)
($26,861)
($29,044)
($31,355)
($33,846)
($36,568)
($310,527)
($335,404)
($362,125)
($391,310)
($422,637)
$2,394,038
Exhibit Ill-B
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Number of Participants
Workers
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
1,607
773
812
214
1,799
Year 1
$5,063,978
$1,764,573
Year 2
$5,469,135
$1,905,754
$1,993,622
$2,153,034
$1,011,510
$1,092,402
$4,769,705
$5,151,190
Year 3
$5,906,689
Year 4
$6,379,340
$2,325,308
$2,511,321
$1,179,791
$1,274,190
$5,563,351
$6,008,319
Year 5
$6,889,595
$2,058,252
$2,222,808
$2,400,629
$2,712,242
$1,376,114
$6,488,985
Year 1
$5,342,439
$1,887,852
$1,038,371
$5,080,232
Year 2
$5,769,773
$6,231,432
$6,729,923
$7,268,332
$2,038,865
$2,201,937
$1,121,446
$5,486,594
$5,925,476
Year 1
Year 2
Total Premium Rates
Total Plan Cost
$2,378,181
$2,568,432
$2,154,009
$2,326,283
$2,512,393
$2,713,412
$2,930,508
$1,412,682
$6,911,622
$3,375,857
$1,176,382
$1,329,082
$674,357
$3,179,821
$3,646,219
$3,937,793
$1,270,441
$1,435,291
$728,285
Year 3
$1,372,106
$1,550,270
$786,527
$3,434,017
$3,708,903
Year 4
$4,252,893
$1,481,934
$1,674,214
$849,443
$4,005,591
Year 5
$4,593,063
$1,600,481
$1,808,097
$917,392
$4,325,970
Year 1
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 2
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 3
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 4
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 5
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$1,211,146
$1,308,036
$6,399,629
Employee Contributions
Employer Contribution
Exhibit III-B
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
$1,699,460
$1,835,065
$1,982,067
$2,140,534
$2,311,852
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
($11,339)
Year 2
($12,149)
Year 3
($13,171)
Year 4
($14,087)
Year 5
($15,320)
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
$617,077
$717,227
$312,095
$1,646,399
$666,481
$774,678
$719,734
$777,338
$839,529
$836,503
$903,527
$975,886
$337,089
$364,062
$393,191
$424,656
$1,778,248
$1,920,299
$2,074,056
$2,240,071
($28,886)
($31,168)
($33,588)
($36,464)
($39,381)
($52,687)
($56,935)
($61,465)
($66,420)
($71,741)
$25,058
$27,028
($56,515)
($61,075)
($65,851)
($71,328)
($77,056)
$29,202
$31,556
$34,066
Exhibit III-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Number of Participants
Workers
1,607
773
812
214
1,799
$5,063,978
$5,469,135
$1,764,573
$1,905,754
Year 4
$5,906,689
$6,379,340
$2,058,252
$2,222,808
$1,011,510
$1,092,402
$1,179,791
$1,274,190
$4,769,705
$5,151,190
$5,563,351
$6,008,319
Year 5
$6,889,595
$2,400,629
$1,993,622
$2,153,034
$2,325,308
$2,511,321
$2,712,242
$1,376,114
$6,488,985
Year 1
$5,342,439
$1,887,852
$1,038,371
Year 2
$2,038,865
$2,201,937
$5,080,232
$5,486,594
Year 4
$5,769,773
$6,231,432
$6,729,923
Year 5
$7,268,332
Total Premium Rates
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Total Plan Cost
Year 3
$2,378,181
$2,568,432
$2,154,009
$2,326,283
$2,512,393
$2,713,412
$2,930,508
$1,329,082
$1,435,291
$1,550,270
$1,674,214
$1,808,097
$917,392
$3,179,821
$3,434,017
$3,708,903
$4,005,591
$4,325,970
$1,121,446
$1,211,146
$1,308,036
$1,412,682
$5,925,476
$6,399,629
$6,911,622
Employee Contributions
Year 1
$3,375,857
Year 2
$3,646,219
Year 3
$3,937,793
Year 4
$4,252,893
Year 5
$4,593,063
$1,176,382
$1,270,441
$1,372,106
$1,481,934
$1,600,481
Year 1
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 2
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 3
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 4
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
Year 5
$0
$0
$0
$0
$0
$674,357
$728,285
$786,527
$849,443
Employer Contribution
Exhibit IIl-C
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Cost Using Developed Premium Rates
Actual Cost 5% Lower than Expected
66.67% Employee Contribution
Age Based
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Health Plan Contribution
Year 1
$805,863
$932,627
$415,933
$2,154,423
Year 2
$2,233,704
$2,412,043
$870,367
$1,007,306
$449,233
Year 3
$2,605,211
$939,928
$1,087,743
$485,176
$2,326,906
$2,512,847
Year 4
:
$2,813,526
:
$3,038,686
$1,015,156
$523,995
$1,096,373
$1,174,869
$1,268,936
$565,924
$2,714,020
$2,931,233
($217,672)
($235,054)
($253,782)
($274,282)
($296,225)
($268,087)
($289,563)
($312,705)
($337,762)
($364,791)
($78,780)
($85,116)
($91,912)
($99,248)
($107,202)
($564,539)
($609,733)
($658,399)
($711,292)
($768,218)
Year 5
Est Gain/(Loss) to Health Plan
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
($545,583)
($589,127)
($636,315)
($687,079)
($742,154)
Exhibit IV
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Census Assumptions Used in Analysis
PARTICIPATION ASSUMPTIONS
Composite
Under 25
25-39
40-64
Total
Total Eligible
48,000
15,000
17,000
16,000
48,000
33.3% Contribution
34,198
12,175
13,578
8,442
34,195
66.7% Contribution
1,607
773
812
214
1,799
35,805
12,948
14,390
8,656
35,994
Total Participating
Exhibit V
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Participation Based Premiums Per Month
Recom’d
Participation Level
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
Rates
Premium Rate
Composite
$229.12 $235.99 $242.87 $257.68 $268.97 $274.53 $287.11
$262.60
Under 25
$175.58 $180.85 $186.11 $197.46 $206.11 $210.38 $220.02
$190.23
25-39
$188.31
$193.96 $199.61 $211.78 $221.06 $225.63 $235.97
$204.60
40-64
$322.68 $332.36 $342.04 $362.90 $378.80 $386.63 $404.35
$393.89
Exhibit VI
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Monthly Contributions at Various Participation Levels
Recom'd
Participation Level
Cont % Category
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
Rates
33.3% Contribution
Under 25
$58.53
$60.28
$62.04
$65.82
$68.70
$70.13
$73.34
$63.41
25-39
$62.77
$64.65
$66.54
$70.59
$73.69
$75.21
$78.66
$68.20
$120.97 $126.27 $128.88 $134.78
$131.30
40-64
Composite
$107.56 $110.79 $114.01
$76.37
$78.66
$80.96
$85.89
$89.66
$91.51
$95.70
$87.53
Under 25
$1 17.06 $120.56 $124.08 $131.64 $137.40 $140.26 $146.68
$126.82
25-39
$125.54 $129.30 $133.08 $141.18 $147.38 $150.42 $157.32
$136.40
40-64
$215.12 $221.58 $228.02 $241.94 $252.54 $257.76 $269.56
$262.60
Composite
$152.74 $157.32 $161.92 $171.78 $179.32 $183.02 $191.40
$175.06
66.7% Contribution
Exhibit VII
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Base Cost Assumptions
Frequency
per 1000
Members
Average
Per Capita
Monthly
Charge
Claims Cost
Frequency
Amount
of per
of per
Per Capita
Monthly
Per Capita
Monthly
Service
Service
Cost Sharing
Claims Cost
Copay
Copay
Value
After Copav
Hospital Inpatient
Non-Maternity
Medical
135
$1,279.63
$14.40
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$14.40
Surgical
142
$2,329.16
$27.46
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$27.46
Neonatal
21
$4,658.33
$8.32
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$8.32
Psychiatric
76
$1,215.65
$7.71
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$7.71
Alcohol & Drug Abuse
41
$972.52
$3.30
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$3.30
Maternity
Normal Deliveries
20
$1,192.15
$2.02
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$2.02
Cesarean Deliveries
19
$1,943.91
$3.13
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$3.13
Non-Deliveries
11
$1,324.19
$1.26
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1.26
5
$883.39
$0.39
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.39
Abortions
Boarder Babies
19
$395.06
$0,64
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.64
Skilled Nursing Facility
12
$214.90
$0.21
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.21
Total Hospital Inpatient
502
$1,644.61
$68.85
$0.00
$68.85
Hospital Outpatient
Emergency Room
364
$182.25
$5.53
364.4
$25,00
$0.76
$4.77
Medical
139
$108.77
$1.26
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1,26
Surgery
Radiology
103
$718.00
$6.18
0.0
$0.00
$0,00
$6.18
170
$240.15
$3.40
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$3.40
Pathology
184
$72.36
$1.11
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1.11
Other Services
253
$145.43
$3.07
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$3,07
Maternity Non-Deliveries
7
$210.90
$0.13
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.13
Total Hospital Outpatient
1,221
$203.26
$20.68
$0.76
$19.92
106
$624.82
$5.53
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$5.53
14
$124.96
$0.15
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.15
68
$109.90
$0.63
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.63
$2.02
Physician
Inpatient Surgery
Primary Surgeon
Assistant Surgeon
Anesthesia
Outpatient Surgery
86
$282.99
$2.02
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
Surgical Center
1 16
$239.72
$2.31
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$2.31
Office
253
$125.01
$2.64
0.0
$0,00
$0.00
$2.64
53
$88.71
$0.39
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0,39
OP Hospital
Anesthesia
Maternity
Normal Deliveries
6
$484.84
$0.26
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.26
Cesarean Deliveries
3
$1,126.14
$0.25
0,0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.25
Non-Deliveries
5
$196.33
$0.09
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.09
409
$154.71
$5.27
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$5.27
6
$105.52
$0.05
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.05
$200.28
$0.31
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.31
Inpatient Visits
Hospital Visits
Extended Care Visits
Critical Care Visits
Exhibit VII
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Base Cost Assumptions
Frequency
Amount
Per Capita
of per
of per
Monthly
Per Capita
Monthly
Average
Per Capita
Monthly
Service
Service
Cost Sharing
Claims Cost
Charge
Claims Cost
Copay
Copay
Value
After Copay
5.251
$57.04
$24.96
5,250.6
$5.00
$2.19
$22.77
2
$89.13
$0.01
1.6
$5.00
$0.00
$0.01
Therapeutic Injections
Allergy Testing
129
$70.34
$0.75
128.8
$5.00
$0.05
$0.70
26
$39.93
$0.09
25.9
$5.00
$0.01
$0.08
Allergy Immunotherapy
Diagnostic Testing
239
$10.51
$0.21
239.4
$5.00
$0.10
$0.11
79
$74.07
$0.49
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.49
Frequency
per 1000
Members
Office Visits
Home Visits
Physician (Continued)
Office Visits & Misc. Services
Emergency Room Visits
316
$140.44
$3.70
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$3.70
Consultations
106
$142.01
$1.26
106.1
$5.00
$0.04
$1.21
Physical Medicine
334
$30.51
$0.85
333.9
$5.00
$0.14
$0.71
Occupational Therapy
Speech Therapy
Chiropractor
Urgent Care
276
$47.93
$1.10
275.9
$5.00
$0.1 1
$0.99
10
$93.03
$0.07
9.6
$5.00
$0.00
$0.07
0
$26.61
$0.00
0.0
$5.00
$0.00
$0.00
1,155
$98.31
$9.46
1,155.0
$5.00
$0.48
$8.98
Total Physician
9,066
$81.29
$62.84
$3.14
$59.71
Radiology
IP (Professional)
137
$67.53
$0.77
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.77
OP (Professional)
337
$89.27
$2.51
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$2.51
Office (Combined)
494
$98.86
$4.07
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$4.07
MRI
3
$796.84
$0.20
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.20
CT-Scan
2
$479.85
$0.08
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.08
972
$93.99
$7.61
$0.00
$7.61
Total Radiology
Pathology
IP (Professional)
OP (Professional)
66
$21.19
$0.12
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.12
125
$32.95
$0.34
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.34
Office (Combined)
3,059
$35.77
$9.12
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$9.12
Total Pathology
3,250
$35.36
$9.58
$0.00
$9.58
$28.91
Other Services
9,170
$42.83
$32.73
9,170.1
$5.00
$3.82
PDN/Homc Health Care
32
$50.18
$0.13
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.13
Ambulance
15
$71.37
$0.09
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.09
Durable Medical Equipment
29
$103.13
$0.25
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.25
3
$318.54
$0.09
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.09
9,249
$43.18
$33,29
$3.82
$29.47
Prescription Drugs
Prosthetics
Total Other Services
Exhibit VII
Santa Clara Family Health Plan
Small Group Insurance Program
Base Cost Assumptions
Frequency
per 1000
Average
Per Capita
Monthly
Members
Charge
Claims Cost
Frequency
of per
Amount
Per Capita
Per Capita
of per
Service
Service
Monthly
Cost Sharing
Claims Cost
Conav
Copav
Value
After Copav
Monthly
Additional Services
Immunizations
Physical Exams
401
$35.79
$1.20
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1.20
94
$59.26
$0.46
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.46
Well Woman Exams
195
$59.26
$0.96
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.96
Vision Exams
262
$53.49
$1.17
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1.17
Speech Exams
210
$90.21
$1.58
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$1.58
4
$62.31
$0.02
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.02
105
$264.81
$2.32
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$2.32
4
$45.89
$0.02
0.0
$0.00
$0.00
$0.02
Abortions
4
$83.67
$0.03
4.3
$5.00
$0.00
$0.03
Podiatrist
60
$78.29
$0.39
60.1
$5.00
$0.03
$0.37
203
$162.49
$2.75
203.0
$5.00
$0.08
$2.66
30
$117.50
$0.30
30.2
$5.00
$0.01
$0.28
1,574
$85.35
$11.19
$0.12
$11.07
25,834
$99.47
$214.05
$7.84
$206.21
Hearing Exams
Hearing Aids
Family Planning
OP Psychiatric
OP Alcohol & Drug Abuse
Total Additional Setv'ices
Total All Services
Cost with Administrative Loading
$229.12
Document
Santa Clara Family Health Plan Small Group Insurance Program expected cost analysis to determine the expected monthly cost of providing medical coverage in currently uninsured individuals who work for small employers
Initiative
Collection
James T. Beall, Jr.
Content Type
Report
Resource Type
Document
Date
08/07/2006
District
District 4
Language
English
Rights
No Copyright: http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/NoC-US/1.0/